Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website.

by Maddie Grant on October 6, 2009

Heard about Google Sidewiki? You need to check it out. This is important. Sidewiki is basically a collapsible browser sidebar (available by free download) that currently works with Firefox (as part of the Google toolbar) and IE. It allows anyone to comment on any website. People can also share what they commented on Twitter, Facebook or by email. (So if you’ve decided to have a blog which doesn’t allow comments, you’re SOL on that one. It’s only a matter of time.)


Here’s more from the Google blog
. The comments will not be viewed “most recent first” but will be ranked according to some Googley algorithm. This has already hit a few snags (for example people commenting are finding it hard to find their own comments on pages with a lot of them) but it’s a new tool so I expect it will take a while before all the bugs are ironed out.

Reactions to this have been mixed. Tom Humbarger has a list of positive and negative reactions to this in the tech blogosphere. Jeremiah Owyang provides a useful summary of the implications, Jeff Jarvis says it spells “danger”, and Phil Baumann tests it out on Seth Godin’s famously no-comment blog.

Basically, this is important for YOU because even if this is just going to be used by early adopters right now, we’re talking about Google here. Eventually everyone will be using it; and/or other social networks will follow with competing functionality. Jeremiah says Facebook is already working on it… and he tried it on his own blog page:

“I just tried out SideWiki to see how it works. I came to this very post and found out that there are already three comments. I left a comment welcoming folks, and it gave me the option to Tweet it, which I did. …you don’t [even] have to have the plugin for this to work. Which means that this certainly has lower barriers to adoption. A few other field notes? I no longer have to fuss with [captcha] on blogs or name/email/url once I’m logged in to SideWiki, I can comment around the web. Secondly, it centralizes all my comments on my Google profile tool. You do see what Google is doing right? They are turning the whole web into a social network.”

I of course downloaded it and tried it in a few places, and it’s pretty cool (for someone who likes to engage and comment on stuff even if you don’t care what my opinion is – haha). Here’s what I said on ASAE’s site:

2009-10-04_1820

Sorry guys! Just proving a point. I said I love ASAE, but in the same comment I’m promoting YAP as the place for association professionals to go hang out. Now anyone can go to www.asaecenter.org, see the little button on the side that shows there’s a sidewiki comment, and see my comment. You can click on my picture and it will go to my Google profile, where you can see who I am and everything else I’ve commented on.

Here’s another example: I went and commented on my own socialfish.org site. Again, I was the first to comment, so I posted a little welcome message. Now I have no idea if this comment will stay there once other people start commenting, and there doesn’t seem to be a way (yet) to claim your site, but I figure this can’t hurt.

2009-10-04_1821

You still reading? Yes, this mean go on, go do it. Go download Sidewiki, and write a welcome comment on your own website before someone else does. Stat!

Posted in: Uncategorized
Tagged: , ,

29 responses to "Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website."

{ 1 trackback }

Tweets that mention Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. — SocialFish -- Topsy.com
October 6, 2009 at 8:37 am

{ 28 comments }

maddiegrant October 6, 2009 at 12:26 pm

Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. http://ff.im/-9jpt3

ltwhite October 6, 2009 at 12:36 pm

Pretty important stuff RT @maddiegrant: Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. http://ff.im/-9jpt3

SocialFishFood October 6, 2009 at 12:33 pm

Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. http://bit.ly/4dfDFe
#socialfish

Leslie White October 6, 2009 at 8:35 am

Talk about a loss of control of your message and brand! Associations and everyone will have to be hyper-vigilant to monitor their various social media sites. Ahh, another thing to keep risk managers in business (shameless plug for me:-)).

busterratliff October 6, 2009 at 1:05 pm

Will be interesting to see what the implications will be…Get Ready You No Longer Own Your Website http://bit.ly/1ao1QR (via @maddiegrant)

lizcies October 6, 2009 at 1:12 pm

Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. http://ff.im/-9jpt3 (from @maddiegrant)

Andy Grant October 6, 2009 at 10:00 am

I’ve had Google Sidewiki installed since the day of release, and I’ve not been impressed, either with the tool itself, or the quality of the comments I’ve been seeing on many websites. With regard to the tool itself, I have it installed in Firefox 3.5, and it is causing my browser to behave weirdly, with each page I visit doing a little shake, or as I like to a call it, a “judder”. It’s that annoying that I’m considering uninstalling it today. With regard to the comments, I haven’t yet seen anything of value. Most comments on major web sites tend to be “first” type posts, and on smaller sites they are just site owners claiming their territory. Maybe time will tell, but for now it just looks like more noise. I’m also not keen on having another online profile to manage, particularly a Google profile. Now if Facebook were to get their act together……

mbrandonisio October 6, 2009 at 2:51 pm

RT @slopez1: RT @SocialFishFood Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. http://bit.ly/4dfDFe #socialfish

HMAssociates October 6, 2009 at 4:01 pm

Have you tried Google Sidewiki yet? http://ow.ly/sYj2 I just installed it and am playing with it now! ^GG

FSSimon October 6, 2009 at 11:55 pm

Yeah, Sidewiki is scary & intriguing | RT @tweetmeme Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website| SocialFish http://bit.ly/11LqK4

rjleaman October 7, 2009 at 1:40 am

reading @maddiegrant Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. — SocialFish http://ow.ly/sWTn

GeneBrady October 7, 2009 at 1:43 am

RT @maddiegrant Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website http://ff.im/-9jpt3

pr_nonprofit October 7, 2009 at 3:15 am

Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. http://bit.ly/3qUBmR #postrank #nonprofit

Trina Isakson October 7, 2009 at 12:34 am

Woah.

Trina Isakson October 7, 2009 at 12:45 am

Looks like you can “claim” your site with a comment that stays at the top. http://www.google.com/support/toolbar/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=157270

EdBennett October 8, 2009 at 12:15 pm

The Association view of Sidewiki by @maddiegrant http://bit.ly/F6mkd – via @ewengel

MeredithGould October 8, 2009 at 12:34 pm

RT @EdBennett: The Association view of Sidewiki by @maddiegrant http://bit.ly/F6mkd – via @ewengel

EdBennett October 8, 2009 at 12:17 pm

Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website by @maddiegrant http://bit.ly/F6mkd – via @ewengel

jasonvoelker October 8, 2009 at 12:42 pm

RT @EdBennett: Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website by @maddiegrant http://bit.ly/F6mkd – via @ewengel

kshe October 8, 2009 at 1:20 pm

RT @EdBennett: Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website by @maddiegrant http://bit.ly/F6mkd – via @ewengel

bluestarlounge October 8, 2009 at 12:36 pm

Nice Blog Post: Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website by @maddiegrant http://bit.ly/F6mkd – via @ewengel @EdBennett

ImpressionOne October 8, 2009 at 12:40 pm

The days of opposing open commenting are over. RT @EdBennett: Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website by @maddiegrant http://bit.ly/F6mkd

Kevin Shannon October 8, 2009 at 8:44 am

I think the outcry about this is really blown out of proportion. There are hundreds of ways people can talk about you on the internet. Review sites, blogs, twitter, facebook. It’s all over and in most cases companies are not even aware they are being talked about. All Google did here was create a communication channel that can be displayed next to the site it’s talking about.

Some things to note:

It’s currently only available to people that have the Google toolbar installed and are logged in with a Google account. There is a bookmarklet called Sidewinder that allows someone without the Google toolbar to just display the comments for a page. So you do have to be authenticated to Google.

Google searchwiki has been available for over a year. If you are logged on with a Google account and you do a search, you can add comments attached to any search result, and any other Google user will see there are comments if the same result comes up for them in a search. Has that function caused any major outcry. It’s basically the same thing.

My guess is if your site is registered with Google Webmaster Tools, they will eventually add a way for you to be notified when comments are made about any of your pages.

I’ve heard people say, “I already have my own commenting tool and this splits the conversation and removes any control I have to remove and edit comments.”

That may be a BAD thing for some…. I think it’s a GOOD thing. You shouldn’t be editing the stream of what people say about you to spin your own message. When I look at review sites, there’s always fringe comments that you can tell don’t jive with the bulk of reviews and you just automatically self edit them. If someone posts something on sidewiki that you disagree with, post a response, just like you would if they posted something wrong about you on Twitter, or facebook or on their blog.

To me this is just another communication vehicle. If it becomes as popular as searchwiki, we have nothing to worry about. Most average internet users don’t even know it exists.

danielcollins October 8, 2009 at 1:13 pm

Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. — SocialFish: http://bit.ly/13xqWE – another stupid idea from Google.

geonetric October 8, 2009 at 1:35 pm

RT @tweetmeme Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. — SocialFish http://bit.ly/11LqK4 More on Google Sidewiki

GayleRas October 16, 2009 at 6:12 pm

Interesting…Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website.
http://tinyurl.com/yf77fl6

xaotic October 18, 2009 at 7:05 am

synectic: Get Ready. You No Longer Own Your Website. http://cli.gs/EuEyn #greader

markkerr October 26, 2009 at 9:18 pm

Anyone else wonder what #Google #Sidewiki means for branding? Get Ready: You No Longer Own Your Website http://ow.ly/wHnn

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: